Verdict
Buy the Brother MFC-L5710DW for a fast business mono laser with a 50-page document feeder and 11,000-page toner. Buy the MFC-L5915DW if you scan and copy a lot: it lists a 70-page feeder and the 18,000-page ultra high-yield toner.
Brother MFC-L5710DW vs Brother MFC-L5915DW: At a Glance
| Brother MFC-L5710DW | Brother MFC-L5915DW | |
|---|---|---|
| Print and copy speed | Up to 48 pages a minute, per listing | Up to 50 pages a minute, per listing |
| Replacement toner | TN920XXL super high-yield, 11,000 pages | TN920UXXL ultra high-yield, 18,000 pages |
| Starter toner | Genuine 3,000-page cartridge included | Genuine 3,000-page cartridge included |
| Document feeder | 50 pages, 2-sided single-pass scanning up to 60 images a minute | 70 pages, 2-sided single-pass scanning up to 56 images a minute |
| Scanning extras | Scan to cloud, email, SharePoint and SFTP from the touchscreen | See listing; large glass handles up to legal-size |
| Connectivity | Gigabit Ethernet and dual-band wireless | Gigabit Ethernet and dual-band wireless |
| Print technology | Monochrome laser | Monochrome laser |
Source: manufacturer and retailer listings for each model. Confirm specs on the current listing before buying.
Choose the Brother MFC-L5710DW if…
You print and scan at a steady office pace and want fast duplex scanning (60 images a minute listed) without paying for the biggest toner capacity.
Check Brother MFC-L5710DW on Amazon
Choose the Brother MFC-L5915DW if…
You run high page volumes and want the longest gap between toner changes: the 18,000-page ultra high-yield cartridge and 70-page feeder suit a busy small office.
Check Brother MFC-L5915DW on Amazon
Who should skip both
If you print only a few pages a week, a compact laser is plenty. If you need color, see mono laser vs color laser.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between the MFC-L5710DW and MFC-L5915DW?
The L5915DW lists 50 ppm, a 70-page document feeder and an 18,000-page ultra high-yield toner. The L5710DW lists 48 ppm, a 50-page feeder and an 11,000-page toner.
Do both print in color?
No. Both are monochrome laser printers.
Do both print double-sided automatically?
Both are listed with duplex printing. Confirm on the current listing before buying.
Which is cheaper to run?
Toner yield is higher on the L5915DW, which usually lowers cost per page. See toner vs ink cost per page.
Comparison based on published manufacturer specifications and listing details. Confirm current prices and specifications before buying. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.